Paper reviewer comments example

Author: mbhj

August undefined, 2024

Webpeer review appears to make papers more readable and improve the general quality of reporting (2 studies), but the evidence for this has very limited generalizability. Authors’ conclusions At present, little empirical evidence is available to support the use of editorial peer review as a mechanism to ensure quality of biomedical research. Webimprove the work and address their concerns as per the specific comments below. As noted by the Reviewer, the authors feel that the length restraint of a Brief Communication …

Reviewer comments: examples for common peer review decisions

WebComments from Reviewer 2 Comment 1: [Paste the full comment here and italicize it.] Response: [Follow the patterns recommended above.] Comment 2: Response: Additional clarifications [Here, mention any other clarifications you would like to provide to the journal editor/reviewer.] WebThe reviewers pointed out several instances where some additional clarification would be very helpful for the reader. For example, reviewer 2 (Comment 1) writes, “I believe the distinction between a “collaborative” system needs to be more clearly distinguished from collective system in the intro. the second advent of jesus christ

Reviewer Comments and Responses - CDC

Webbackground/literature review. 17. The distinction between racial category and racial markers (16/last/last) needs to be better defined/described and moved to the very beginning of the paper. 18. What “other applications are possible” (17/3/2-3)? 19. The limitations section of the paper is, well, too limited (see my comments throughout). WebReviewers’ Comments and Authors Response Paper number: ADHOC-D-13-37 ... Reviewer #2: This paper has a potential to be accepted, but some important points have to be ... We would appreciate if the reviewer could provide more precise examples of unconvincing and vague results. We would also like to point out that this study is focused on ... WebDec 17, 2024 · Peer review, sometimes referred to as refereeing, is the process of evaluating submissions to an academic journal. Using strict criteria, a panel of reviewers in the same … my pillow theme song lyrics

Reviewer comments: examples for common peer review decisions

Peer Review – Best Practices : Broad Institute of MIT and Harvard

Web1. The work lacks scientific merit - the manuscript does not make any significant improvement to the intended field of research. 2. Personal biases are elevated above … WebExamples of possibly major flaws include: Drawing a conclusion that is contradicted by the author's own statistical or qualitative evidence The use of a discredited method Ignoring a … my pillow textsWebPeer review of journal articles and other technical reports is a key element in the maintenance of academic integrity. This article assists the reader in the efficient preparation of constructive reviews. The parts of a typical review are listed, as well as formats for the most common situations. Common defects of technical papers are discussed. the second amendment is a curse

"WebSample peer review comments to reject a manuscript “I do not believe that this journal is a good fit for this paper.” “While the paper addresses an interesting issue, it is not … " - Paper reviewer comments example

Paper reviewer comments example

Reviewing a Journal Article (Peer Review) - University of …

WebMar 6, 2024 · One Step At a Time. When you are ready to start, a helpful approach is to resolve one comment at a time. Read it and understand what it is actually asking, and then make notes of how you will respond and what you will be required to do to make the changes in the manuscript. This process should be repeated for all of the comments … WebReviewer Comments to Author(s): Reviewer #1 (Jillon Vander Wal, PhD): Overall, this is a clear, concise, and well-written manuscript. The introduction is relevant and theory based. …

Did you know?

WebFor example, instead of, “The explanation of the proposed mechanism is not clear. ” You might write, “The explanation of the proposed mechanism should be more detailed. … Keeping in mind the guidelines above, how do you put your thoughts into words? Here are some sample “before” and “after” reviewer comments ✗ Before “The authors appear to have no idea what they are talking about. I don’t think they have read any of the literature on this topic.” ✓ After “The study fails to address … See more Use an outline for your reviewer report so it’s easy for the editors and author to follow. This will also help you keep your comments organized. Think about structuring your review like an inverted pyramid. Put the most … See more Giving feedback is hard. Giving effective feedback can be even more challenging. Remember that your ultimate goal is to discuss what the authors would need to do in order to qualify for publication. The point is not to nitpick … See more You might find yourself in a situation where you’re not sure how to explain the problem or provide feedback in a constructive and … See more Be sure you turn in your report on time. Need an extension? Tell the journal so that they know what to expect. If you need a lot of extra time, the … See more

WebApr 7, 2024 · April 7, 2024. WASHINGTON — A new batch of classified documents that appear to detail American national security secrets from Ukraine to the Middle East to China surfaced on social media sites ... WebSample comments Please note that these are just examples of how you might provide feedback on an author’s work. You should, of course, always tailor your review to the …

WebDec 17, 2024 · Example: Peer review comments Influence of phone use on sleep Studies show that teens from the US are getting less sleep than they were a decade ago (Johnson, 2024). On average, teens only slept for 6 hours a night in … WebPaper Reviews: Sample Paper Reviews Print Page Report a broken link Explanations of errors Links to resources Questions or reactions from a reader’s perspective Recommended next steps Revision strategies Highlighted patterns Models of effective writing Video clips to watch Sample Review of a Discussion Post (PDF)

WebReviewers' Comments to the Authors: Reviewer 1 . There are numerous strengths to this study, including its diverse sample and wellinformed hypotheses.- Author response: …

WebApr 5, 2024 · For example, if the reviewer seems confused about something, improve the clarity in your paper. If you disagree with the reviewer, include better justification for … the second 300 movieWebApr 3, 2024 · Your responses should be polite and objective, balancing the line between being concise and complete. There is no space for ego in your response. Start by thanking … the second ai winterWebThe reviewers read the paper and provide comments, suggestions and a recommendation (reject, revise or accept). ... Sample comments. Please note that these are just examples of how you might provide feedback on an author’s work. You should, of course, always tailor your review to the paper in question and the specific requirements of the ... my pillow text for 10 offWebExamples of ‘major revisions’ reviewer comments “The manuscript shows a lot of promise, but some major issues need to be addressed before it can be published.” “This … my pillow that rolls upWebApr 6, 2024 · Discover peer review templates, example reports, and the Web of Science™ Academy: our free, online course that teaches you the core competencies of peer review through practical experience Company … the second amendment isWebexample of cover letter that can go with y our resp onse to reviewers’ comments is pro vided. The specimen/template is made up of a set of parts, each of which is presented and described in a ... my pillow thongsWebApr 1, 2011 · 3. Wait and Gather Your Thoughts. After you read the decision letter from the editor and see the reviewers' comments, take at least a day to allow yourself to process what both the editor and reviewers have said. Then take a fresh look at the comments to determine what the reviewers want to see in a revised paper. my pillow thickness